$17 million verdict against Genesis Energy over trucker’s collision up on appeal


BEAUMONT – Two years ago, a jury awarded a local man more than $17 million in damages for injuries he received when a truck driver for Genesis Energy slammed into the rear of his smoking vehicle.

Now, the Ninth Court of Appeals is being asked by Genesis Entergy to reverse the judgment in its entirety. 

Case history

Dezmon Simpson filed the lawsuit in March 2017 and also named Two Amigos Auto Repair and James Benfield (the truck driver) as defendants.

According to the plaintiff’s petition, on Feb. 13, 2017, Simpson was traveling south on I-10 when the GMC Terrain he was driving began to lose power and smoke started billowing out, forcing him to move right to get off the interstate.

Benfield, who was driving a tractor-trailer pulling a load of toxic chemicals, was traveling behind Simpson and struck the rear of his vehicle, crushing the rear end and forcing it to careen off of the median wall.

“Defendant driver Benfield was suffering from sleep apnea, exhaustion and fatigue from long hours on duty for Genesis Energy,” the suit states. “Benfield was trying to stay awake as he approached the cloud of smoke caused by Simpson’s car but video shows he was falling asleep in the seconds prior to impact.”

The suit also states Benfield’s vehicle was still on cruise control when the collision occurred and that he made no effort to avoid the collision or even brake.

Court records show the GMC Terrain belonged to Yulonda Eldridge and that Two Amigos Auto Repair had serviced the vehicle prior to the incident.

Court records show Two Amigos was non-suited before the case went to trial.

The trial lasted for three weeks and came to a conclusion on Dec. 11, 2019 with jurors finding no negligence on Simpson’s part, assigning all the blame to Genesis Energy and Benfield.

Jurors awarded Simpson $180,778.98 for his past medical expenses, $1.5 million for future medical care, $4 million for his past and future physical pain, $5.5 million for his past and future mental anguish, $3 million for his past and future impairment, $4 million for his future loss of earning capacity and $15,000 for past disfigurement.

Eldridge was awarded $20,000 for her loss of property.

The jury also found that the harm inflicted upon Simpson resulted from gross negligence.

Beaumont attorney Clay Dugas represents Simpson.

Genesis Energy is represented by Randy Fairless and Timothy Nisbet of the Sugar Land law firm Johanson & Fairless.

The appeal is set for submission on briefs for Dec. 21, court records show

Judge Baylor Wortham, 136th District Court, presided over the trial.

Trial case No. D-199677

Appeals case No. 09-20-00109-CV  

Written by Staff reports

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s